IoC Container Vs. Service Locator

This post has migrated to https://beginningprogrammer.com/programming/ioc-container-vs-service-locator/

Comments

Derick Bailey said…
great post, Fernando! I had IoC vs ServiceLocator confused for the last 3 years, honestly. I had to go back and re-read that Fowler article a few times in the last week before it really sunk in.

Be careful about saying "coding against abstractions. In C# we use interfaces" - abstraction does not imply interface, even in C#.

http://www.lostechies.com/blogs/derickbailey/archive/2008/10/20/dependency-inversion-abstraction-does-not-mean-interface.aspx
March 23, 2009 at 2:07 PM
Fernando Zamora said…
Derick, you are absolutely right. I didn't give it think it trough when I wrote that line. Abstractions appear in every language in many different forms. Anything that hides the implementation details for that matter is a form of abstraction. Abstraction is the "what" hiding the "how".
March 23, 2009 at 2:19 PM
Alexander Steshenko said…
A service locator may as well inject dependencies (using itself to construct them). There is no difference between Service Locator and IoC container if you take them in isolation.

The only difference is how you use them in your application.
June 16, 2012 at 5:57 AM
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Putting Files on the Rackspace File Cloud

Recently, I’ve been playing around with Asp.Net MVC and I (along with some friends) am creating an Asp.Net MVC application that can access files from our website. This means that files must display on the site as well as provide a way to download/upload them. I won’t give away all the details of the project but I will say this: Sharing photos is one of the driving forces for our project.  The files are only image type files( jpg, etc) The files must be uploaded by the users and stored somewhere within our system.  We don’t necessarily know at this time how much storage space we need but we think that we will need a little at first but possibly a lot more down the road. This means that the storage of these files must be scalable. The uploading of files must be controlled by our system.  Right off the bat we started our application and were uploading files to the web server with no problem.  We only did it this way to kind of prove our system model. We wer...
Read more

Setting Up XnaMobileUnit to run unit tests in Windows Phone 7 XNA Games

Image
Introducing XnaMobileUnit I decided to roll my own unit test framework for Windows Phone 7 XNA games.   I have a couple of reasons why I decided to roll my own.  Among them was the fact that you cannot reference regular .Net assemblies from Windows Mobile Framework.  That means that referencing NUnit was out of the question.  Also using some of the other libraries that can be used for Silverlight Applications didn't quite feel right for me. The framework that I have created, XnaMobileUnit, is very simple to use and provides all the necessary functionality to run unit tests.  I am still working on the framework to provide a few more capabilities and features, but for the most part it is ready to use out of the box.  XnaMobileUnit is open source licensed under the Apache 2.0 License and can be downloaded from http://code.google.com/p/xna-mobile-unit/ .  I recommend downloading the latest source and compiling it then referencing the new DLL. Othe...
Read more

Reasons to Stay Away from CSLA

We've been using CSLA - Component-based Scalable Logical Architecture in a product for approximately one year and while it solves quite a few problems it violates some major good practices. No Clear Separation of Layers While at the time that we chose CSLA we knew very little about domain driven design, it is no excuse for the framework to possess the data access layer within the business object. This makes it extremely difficult to separate the concerns. As a result, it is difficult to mock the data-access layer creating many problems when attempting to perform unit tests. This also puts the additional responsibility of data access on the business object class, violating the Single Responsibility Principle( SRP ). Data access layer should be totally separated from the business object period. Having the data access within the within the BO class is not the only additional responsibility placed on the class but is the most significant one I can think of. No Context Validation...
Read more